PROVIDENCE, R.I. — A mural in downtown Providence has sparked growing controversy, with Mayor Brett Smiley now calling for it to be taken down as debate continues over its message and funding.
The artwork, located on the exterior of The Dark Lady on Snow Street, was created as a tribute to Iryna Zarutska, a 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee who was killed last summer. However, the project remains unfinished as tensions build among city officials, resident and those involved.
Mayor raises concerns over message
The Mayor’s Office confirmed that Smiley is seeking the mural’s removal.
In a statement, he said while the victim’s death was tragic, he believes projects like this have become divisive and do not bring the community together.
City officials have not yet outlined any legal or regulatory basis for removing the mural.
Tribute becomes political flashpoint
Although intended as a memorial, the mural has drawn national attention.
Zarutska’s case has been cited by figures including Donald Trump in broader political debates about crime and the justice system.
The project has also faced scrutiny over funding tied in part to Elon Musk.
Artist and community reactions
Artist Ian Gaudreau said the work was never intended to carry a political message.
Some residents visiting the site have echoed that view, urging others to focus on honoring the victim rather than the controversy.
Business owners feel impact
The situation has also affected the owners of The Dark Lady.
Questions remain
The city has said the mural was not commissioned or funded by Providence and was not formally registered.
As of now, it remains unclear what steps, if any, the city can take to require its removal.
ContributorMarch 30, 20261 Mins read24 
The Mayor wants it removed. Talk about a contradiction to the whole no kings rally that took place over the weekend.