In a letter to Patel, Smiley expressed gratitude to the FBI and partnering law enforcement agencies for what he described as “130 uninterrupted hours” of work that brought an end to a six-day manhunt spanning New England.
While praising the investigation’s “rigorous police work,” Smiley emphasized that the breakthrough was also driven by hundreds of tips from Providence residents. One tip, however, stood apart. Smiley highlighted a single source — identified only as “John” — whose information he said was crucial to solving the case.
An FBI spokesperson responded to inquiries Friday night, stating that it is standard agency policy not to disclose whether a reward has been paid or to whom.
Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha said John’s information “blew the case wide open.” According to an affidavit, after seeing a Reddit post and images circulating publicly, John approached a police officer near the Brown campus and offered assistance.
John told investigators he encountered the suspect, later identified as Claudio Manuel Neves Valente, before the shooting inside a Brown classroom that left two students dead and nine others injured. He said he confronted the gunman and described a brief “cat-and-mouse” encounter that ended with Neves Valente leaving the area.
John also helped police identify the suspect’s rental vehicle, a gray Nissan sedan, which he said was parked behind the Rhode Island Historical Society on the Cooke Street side. He reported finding the vehicle suspicious after watching Neves Valente unlock it with a key fob, only to step away without entering.
Police were able to identify the Nissan as having Florida license plates, which were captured using Flock camera technology. The registration led investigators to a Boston-area car rental agency, where records identified Neves Valente. Surveillance images later confirmed his identity.
ContributorDecember 20, 20251 Mins read60 
Leave a comment